University of Hertfordshire

From the same journal

A Trojan Horse for Sociology? Preferences versus Evolution and Morality

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Documents

  • Geoffrey Hodgson
View graph of relations
Original languageEnglish
Number of pages20
Pages (from-to)93-112
JournalReview of Behavioral Economics
Journal publication date29 Jul 2015
Volume2
Issue1-2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 29 Jul 2015

Abstract

Herbert Gintis and Dirk Helbing have developed a highly impressive, over-arching theoretical framework, using rational choice theory, general equilibrium theory, and game theory. They extend this to cover “moral, social and other-regarding values,” plus social norms, culture, and institutions. While accepting the value of their contribution, I argue that there is a tension within their work between their depiction of the rational choice framework as a general “expression” of behavior and searching for explanations of, and detailed motivations for, particular phenomena such as punishment, altruism or moral sentiments. There is also a danger of over-generalization where a framework is stretched to cover every possible behavior. Indeed, rational choice theory with “other-regarding” preferences is strictly unfalsifiable. Furthermore, because “other regarding” agents are also depicted as maximizing their own utility, this framework cannot encompass adequate notions of altruism or morality. Instead we should follow Darwin in seeking to explain the evolution of morality as a distinctly human motivation. The article concludes with a discussion of the implications of the Gintis-Helbing arguments for the future of sociology as a separate discipline.

Notes

This document is the Accepted Manuscript version of the following article: Geoffrey M. Hodgson, ‘A Trojan Horse for Sociology? Preferences versus Evolution and Morality’, Review of Behavioral Economics, Vol. 2 (1-2): 93-112. The Version of Record is available online at DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1561/105.00000021. © 2015 G. M. Hodgson. Published by Now Publishers Inc.

ID: 10871807